The Indian Sportal

Portal for Local Indian Sports - TIS Pune

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Take that, Sports Ministry!

E-mail Print PDF

Well, in a way! Not more than a few days ago, the Sports Ministry of India had this to say,

The proposed F1 race does not satisfy conditions which focus on human endeavor for excelling in competition with others, keeping in view the whole sports movement from Olympics downwards.

With Force India having the best result in their F1 career, I think it may be time to reconsider. Now first of all, I am not saying that it’s a victory for India. Vijay Mallya may own the team, but when Chelsea won the Premier League, it wasn’t a victory for Russia. So, my point here is make people realize that we have to make hay while the sun shines.

A sport is defined, by the Oxford dictionary, as “an activity involving physical exertion and skill in which an individual or team competes against another or others”. Now how does Formula One not fall under this definition of sport. Who does the Ministry think they are trying to fool? “Physical exertion” and “skill”, don’t these phrases connect with F1? And commercial interests; tell me who does not have them. But with that if you have the ability to ignite something that needs just a small spark, why stop it? I would like the Ministry to make public the “conditions” which are required to call a sport a sport. Let’s get them out and then let them ponder in the stupidity of their statement. Let us understand what the “Sports” Ministry wants to call sports.

The Ministry wants to focus on human endeavor for excelling competition with others. What does that even mean? What are they trying to tell us? And how does F1 not constitute a part of this. What I do not understand is why the Ministry is shying away from making some money it needs. I am not going to sit idly and agree that the IPL was a “human endeavor for excelling in competition with others”. Yes, the BCCI had not asked for money from the Ministry for it, but then, it is clear to everyone that IPL has not a lot to do with competition and the Ministry’s definition of sport. It was so much to do with money. There they are, those players and organizers, stuffing their pockets with cash. Don’t tell me they were doing it for the game. What is Twenty20 but another way to pull in people to watch, and in turn, make money.

And calling Formula 1 entertainment is simply a joke. Take IPL again for example. That wasn’t entertainment, with the fireworks and the cheerleaders? Songs being played after every over, wicket and boundary? Call that pure sport and I give up. Then there would be no use even mentioning my agitation at the Ministry’s position on Formula 1. Just because you don’t understand it, does not mean it is not what it is.

Now getting back to my point about making hay while the sun shines. There is a huge following for F1 in India. I know that, you know that. It figures, when it has been more than 10 years that it is being broadcast live on TV. We have even played the Fantasy game with extreme passion, postponing parties to coincide with races. The next thing to happen should surely be a race that is to be held in India. By supporting this idea, the Ministry is only in a win-win situation. It complains that the technology is far ahead of that in India. Well, that’s the case for most of the world. How many people around the world can afford a car with paddle shifters, a transmission that can shift in micro-seconds? What car is completely made of carbon fiber and can stop like it hit a wall? And this excuse is even stupider than it sounds; won’t it seem a waste of time to see a car go round and round in the same car you may drive everyday to work? With the following for F1 that India has, and with the new technology on hand, and with the chance of making some money, why does the Ministry have to make excuses. Mr. Gill has decided to stand by his statement. I would like to remind him that there is a fine line between being firm and being stubborn. We’ve had a driver driving an F1 car, a billionaire who now owns one and is the team principal. Now what remains is a race in India.

Comments
Search
"its not a sport"
avatar
jo_aditya (Publisher) 2009-09-03 19:25:15

This statement is being publicly criticised by F1 fans but they forget that they
are pulling and thrashing the statement out of its real context
What sports
ministry explicitly mentioned was that F1 was more dependent on technology
rather than personal skill. I have no arguments that skill is necessary, but
then again, all of us will surely agree to the fact that tehnology is far more
important in F1. So thier stand, from my perspective is quite corrct, especially
taking into consideration, that huge amount of taxpayers money involved. Also,
think of the population, and one will notice that the fan following may be a big
number, but as faar as the chunk is concerned, is meager...
Sports ministry may
have gone wrong in framing their response (as always is the case with ministries
here... this is a country where external affairs ministry messes up
statements... sports ministry is a kid)... but I echo their sentiments
I disagree
avatar
Amod D Kulkarni (Publisher) 2009-09-03 09:53:56

I don't agree to some of the points here...I feel its not correct to blame the
Govt. , Sports Ministry in a way because they too have their hands tied up !!!
They are obliged to use the tax Payers money to the right cause or may i say the
most essential cause first. The comment that F1 is not a 'sport' is debatable to
some extent though...
Only registered users can write comments!

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

Last Updated on Tuesday, 01 September 2009 09:26  
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

The Indian Sportal

How many of you know local heroes? Men and women who have represented their sport at national or state or even inter city level. Interested few know their achievements, but hardly anybody knows them, their stories, their sacrifices and their moments of glory.We believe that their stories need to be told. Their talent needs to be showcased. We intend to provide a platform for all such budding sportsmen/women.

CONNECT

We would appreciate any help that you can provide us with. We welcome any suggestions or comments you may have. If you would like us to cover an event or if you want to be a part of our efforts , we would be more than happy to know about it. Please mail us at contactus-at-theindiansportal.com.

TIS Reviews

This is a really wonderful site, you all have built. Congratulations !!! Nice work guys!! - Regards,Amarendra

Congratulations on starting the sports Portal. That has been a long felt need for the Sports Lovers of Pune and I am sure your portal will become a hit soon. - Bobby Jacob